Thursday, March 7, 2024

Opinion Today: Should either of these people have the power to end the world?

The president's sole authority to use nuclear weapons needs to be re-examined in today's world.
Continue reading the main story
Ad
Opinion Today

March 7, 2024

Author Headshot

By Kathleen Kingsbury

Opinion Editor

A large majority of Americans say they don't trust a government run by the opposition party. So we must ask ourselves: Is it moral, just and wise to vest the ability to end other nations in the hands of one person?

"As president, I carried no wallet, no money, no driver's license, no keys in my pockets — only secret codes that were capable of bringing about the annihilation of much of the world as we knew it," Ronald Reagan wrote in his autobiography.

That's right. President Biden this very minute could unilaterally decide to launch a devastating nuclear strike anywhere in the world in minutes — without a requirement to consult Congress or the courts. The missiles would be in flight before even the most plugged-in Americans knew they'd been launched.

This is an enormous amount of power to grant any single person. That's doubly true in undemocratic nations, several of which have nuclear arsenals of their own.

It is time to explore what alternatives to the president's sole nuclear authority could be, and that's what my colleague W.J. Hennigan does in the latest installment of our series "At the Brink," published this morning.

Mr. Hennigan offers readers a rare look into the U.S. Strategic Command, which operates a global system to ensure that, if a president orders the launch of a nuclear weapon, it will happen in minutes. Along with his compelling reporting and writing, the celebrated photographer An-My LĂȘ captures the men, women and spaces that make up this military operation.

Last year, Senator Ed Markey of Massachusetts and Representative Ted Lieu of California introduced legislation that would prevent any American president from launching a first nuclear strike without congressional approval. Passing this bill or one like it is an obvious step.

Yet the American public is owed a bigger plan on how countries around the globe can work together to reduce nuclear threats. Today nuclear weapons loom over international politics in ways not seen since the Cold War — a dynamic Times Opinion explored in the first installment of the series earlier this week.

The phrase "serious debate" is often tossed around in campaign season. It's a way to insist on talking about something, even if in a nebulous way. Fortunately, there are chances for a substantive public discussion of nuclear weapons, and we invite the country and the world to join in the conversation. Americans might be surprised to hear what those in other nations think.

Times Opinion has invited President Biden and President Trump to explain in our pages what their next administrations would do to reduce these risks. We hope they will do so. We also hope this will be a subject in the upcoming presidential debates. Reporters covering the president and his competitor should press them on their policies and thinking around sole authority and other nuclear policies.

Continue reading the main story

ADVERTISEMENT

Ad

Though Mr. Trump and Mr. Biden "will have to confront questions from voters about their mental acuity, competence and stamina to take on another four-year term," as Mr. Hennigan writes today, "regardless of who wins this election or the next one, the American president's nuclear sole authority is a product of another era, and must be revisited in our new nuclear age."

That should be something that most Americans can agree on.

Read more:

Continue reading the main story

ADVERTISEMENT

Ad

Here's what we're focusing on today:

Editors' Picks

Guest Essay

The Disappearance of Mayor Adams

Unlike most of his predecessors, he has had few accomplishments while leading New York City. But there's still time to change that.

By Nicole Gelinas and Gus Aronson

A view of New York City Hall at night, with a lighted facade.

More From Opinion

Michelle Cottle

Dark Brandon in the House

What President Biden needs to accomplish at Thursday's State of the Union address.

By Michelle Cottle

A photo illustration, in which the head of Joe Biden wearing aviators is on top of a boxer's body, sitting in the corner of a boxing ring with red, white and blue ropes.

Pamela Paul

Civil Discourse on Campus Is Put to the Test

A panel has a lively good-faith discussion, with all sides, on diversity hiring statements.

By Pamela Paul

An illustration depicting a graduation cap and tassel as a speaking podium.

Three Reasons Biden Must Rethink His 2024 Strategy

It will take more than Jan. 6 to convince those voters who are still skeptical.

By Zeynep Tufekci

Article Image

The National Guard Might Help Subway Riders Feel Safer

But Governor Hochul needs to ensure that the state's role is to deter crime, not harass riders.

By Mara Gay

Nicholas Kristof

The School Issues We're Battling Over Aren't the Ones That Matter

What's worse than censoring a book? Kids not being able to read it anyway.

By Nicholas Kristof

A black and white photograph of a girl sitting at a desk with an open book and papers. She holds a pencil in one hand and her face with the other.

Frank Bruni

'Martin Luther King on Steroids'? Meet a Perfect MAGA Mirror.

Trump's pick for North Carolina governor is, like Trump himself, all about ire.

By Frank Bruni

An illustration depicting a black megaphone against a red background with yellow flames shooting out of it, the core of which is a red outline of North Carolina.
Continue reading the main story

ADVERTISEMENT

Ad

Peter Coy

Please, President Biden: Don't Blame Corporate Greed for Inflation

Instead of casting blame, Biden should tout what he's done to ease Americans' financial pressures.

By Peter Coy

An illustration depicting an orange donkey with blue aviator sunglasses.

Jessica Grose

How to Fix the Crisis of Trust in Higher Education

Start listening to students about what makes college relevant.

By Jessica Grose

An illustration of a student rowing a boat in a body of water while the Ionic columns of the facade of a campus building, a diploma, a mortarboard and a sign reading

David Wallace-Wells

John Kerry: 'I Feel Deeply Frustrated'

The departing climate envoy on what the world has and hasn't achieved.

By David Wallace-Wells

Article Image

Despite the Doubters, Haley's Real Goal Was to Be a Choice

People kept asking what she really wanted, but ultimately the party didn't accept her answer.

By Katherine Miller

letters

Reflections on a Trump-Biden Rematch

Readers react to articles about the two candidates' dominance on Super Tuesday. Also: Older bike riders; French abortion amendment; shrinkflation.

Article Image

We hope you've enjoyed this newsletter, which is made possible through subscriber support. Subscribe to The New York Times.

Games Here are today's Mini Crossword, Wordle and Spelling Bee. If you're in the mood to play more, find all our games here.

Forward this newsletter to friends to share ideas and perspectives that will help inform their lives. They can sign up here. Do you have feedback? Email us at opiniontoday@nytimes.com.

If you have questions about your Times account, delivery problems or other issues, visit our Help Page or contact The Times.

Continue reading the main story

Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

You received this email because you signed up for the Opinion Today newsletter from The New York Times.

To stop receiving Opinion Today, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings. To opt out of updates and offers sent from The Athletic, submit a request.

Subscribe to The Times

Connect with us on:

facebooktwitterinstagram

Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices

LiveIntent LogoAdChoices Logo

The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018

No comments:

Post a Comment